Medical billing for behavioral health & CHW practices · Las Vegas & Southern Nevada(702) 775-1163  ·  support@remitready.us

Home › Blog › Secondary claims

November 18, 2026 · By Nathan Pressley, founder of RemitReady

Secondary insurance claims: how a small practice bills the second payer without losing money

When a patient has two insurance plans, the visit is not finished when the first plan pays. Whatever the primary payer leaves behind may belong to a secondary plan, and that balance only gets paid if someone sends the right claim, to the right payer, with the right information attached. In many small practices this is where money quietly goes missing. The primary payment gets posted, the leftover balance gets billed to the patient or written off, and the secondary plan never sees a claim at all.

I have watched this happen since I started MedNet of Michigan in 1991, back when practices were first sending claims electronically. The habits that keep secondary claims from falling through the cracks have not changed much. Here is a practical way for a small practice in Las Vegas, or anywhere in Nevada, to handle the second payer well.

Start at the front desk: get the order right

Secondary billing problems usually begin before the patient is seen. If the practice has the plans in the wrong order, the claim goes to the wrong payer first, and that payer will often deny it and point back to the other plan.

At check-in, ask every patient whether they have any other coverage, not just whether their insurance has changed. Common situations where a second plan exists include a working spouse with family coverage, a patient with both Medicare and a supplement or retiree plan, a child covered by both parents, and patients with Medicaid as the payer of last resort. Record both plans, and confirm the order with eligibility checks. I covered that front-end step in more detail in insurance eligibility verification before the visit.

Understand what coordination of benefits means in practice

Coordination of benefits is simply the set of rules payers use to decide who pays first. You do need to know that the payers will apply them, and that when the patient’s information on file with a payer does not match what the practice sent, claims stall. A short, regular question to patients, “Has anything changed with your other coverage?”, prevents many of these delays. When a payer says it is waiting on the patient to update coordination of benefits information, tell the patient right away and note the date you asked.

Post the primary payment carefully

The secondary claim is built from what the primary payer did. That means the primary remittance has to be posted accurately: the paid amount, each adjustment, and the patient responsibility amounts like deductible, coinsurance and copay, each with its reason code. If the posting lumps everything into one adjustment, the secondary claim will be missing the details the second payer needs to decide what it owes. My earlier post on posting ERA and 835 payments walks through why line-level detail matters.

Send the secondary claim promptly, with the primary details

Once the primary payment is posted, the remaining balance should move to the secondary payer, not to the patient. Depending on the payer and your billing system, that happens in one of two ways:

Do not assume crossover happened. If the remittance does not clearly show it, treat the claim as yours to send. Secondary claims have their own timely filing limits, and some are counted from the primary payer’s processing date. The rules vary by payer, so check each contract. My post on timely filing limits explains how to keep track of them.

Hold the patient statement until the secondary has paid

One of the most common mistakes I see is sending the patient a bill for the full leftover balance the same day the primary pays. The patient calls upset, the front desk has to explain, and sometimes the patient pays an amount the secondary plan would have covered. Later the secondary pays too, and now the practice has a credit balance to refund. A simple rule fixes most of this: when a secondary plan is on file, do not send a patient statement for that visit until the secondary payer has paid or denied. If you have had trouble with the refunds this creates, see credit balances and refunds.

Work secondary balances as their own AR list

In your aging report, secondary balances can hide behind primary balances that are already paid. Pull a separate list of open balances sitting with a secondary payer, sorted by age. Review it on a regular schedule, the same way you work your primary follow-up. Look for claims that were never sent, claims waiting on crossover that never came through, and denials asking for the primary remittance. My weekly AR follow-up rhythm works well for this list too.

Common secondary denials and what they usually mean

Treat each one as a fixable task with an owner and a date, not a reason to move the balance to the patient.

Where to start this week

Pull a list of patients with two plans on file. Pick a handful of recent visits and trace each one: did the primary pay, was the secondary billed, and what happened to the leftover balance? That quick check will tell you whether secondary billing is working or leaking.

Not sure your secondary claims are getting billed? Request a free billing review or call (702) 775-1163. You can also email support@remitready.us. We will look at how balances move from the primary payer to the secondary payer and give you practical next steps whether or not you hire us. Read more posts on the RemitReady blog.