Medical billing for behavioral health & CHW practices · Las Vegas & Southern Nevada(702) 775-1163  ·  support@remitready.us

Home › Blog › Credit balances

November 17, 2026 · By Nathan Pressley, founder of RemitReady

Credit balances and refunds: how a small practice handles overpayments the right way

Most billing conversations are about getting paid. This one is about the opposite problem: money sitting on your books that may not belong to you. When a patient account shows a negative balance, the practice is holding a credit. Sometimes it is a simple timing issue. Sometimes it is a real overpayment that has to go back to a patient or a payer. Either way, a credit balance report that nobody works is a problem waiting to grow.

I started MedNet of Michigan in 1991, back when practices were just learning to send claims electronically. Even then, the offices that stayed out of trouble were the ones that treated credits as seriously as denials. Here is a practical way for a small practice in Las Vegas or anywhere in Nevada to keep credit balances under control.

Where credit balances come from

A credit shows up when more money has been applied to an account than the account owes. The usual causes are ordinary, not dramatic:

Notice that several of these are posting errors, not true overpayments. That is why the first step is always research, not a refund check.

Step one: run the credit balance report regularly

Your practice management system almost certainly has a report of accounts with negative balances. Pick a schedule and keep it, monthly at minimum. Sort by age and by amount so the oldest and largest credits get looked at first. If the report has never been worked, do not panic. Start with the newest month and work backward in batches you can actually finish.

Step two: research each credit before touching it

For every account on the report, open the ledger and the remittances and answer a few questions:

Many credits disappear at this step because the answer is a misapplied payment or an adjustment that needs reversing. Clean ERA posting prevents a lot of this in the first place, which is why I wrote about how to post ERA and 835 payments in a small practice.

Step three: decide who the money belongs to

Once you know the credit is real, figure out whose money it is.

Patient overpayments. If the patient paid more than their responsibility, check first whether they have another open balance with your practice and what your written policy says about applying credits. If there is nothing else owed, the patient is due a refund. Document the amount, the visit and the reason.

Payer overpayments. If a payer paid too much or paid when another payer was primary, the payer is owed money back. Each payer has its own process: some want a refund check with a specific form, some prefer to take it back through an offset on a future remittance. Follow the payer’s instructions and keep a copy of what you sent. Government payers have their own overpayment rules and timelines, so if you bill Medicare or Nevada Medicaid, check their current guidance and talk to your compliance advisor about what applies to you.

Step four: process refunds with a paper trail

Every refund should leave a trail someone else could follow a year from now. Keep a simple refund log with the account, date of service, amount, who was refunded, why, who approved it and when it was sent. Require a second person to approve refunds above an amount your practice chooses. That one control protects both the practice and the staff member doing the work.

Step five: fix the cause, not just the balance

Once a month, look at the credits you resolved and ask why they happened. If most came from front desk estimates, review how estimates are calculated. If they came from two payers paying, tighten insurance verification at check-in; my post on verifying eligibility before the visit walks through that. If they came from posting errors, that is a training or workflow issue worth fixing now.

Why this matters to the practice owner

A credit balance report is easy to ignore because it does not look like lost money. But unresolved credits make your AR numbers less reliable, they frustrate patients who are waiting on refunds, and payer overpayments do not go away just because nobody looked. A short line on credits belongs in the monthly billing report every practice owner should read.

Where automation fits

Pulling the credit report, matching it to remittances and flagging likely posting errors is repetitive work. Our sister team at RemitReady Agents builds AI helpers that can prepare that kind of worklist for a person to review. The decision about who gets refunded stays with someone who understands the account.

Have a credit balance report nobody has worked in a while? Request a free billing review or call (702) 775-1163. You can also email support@remitready.us. We will look at how credits are building up and give you practical next steps whether or not you hire us. Read more posts on the RemitReady blog.