Underpayments: how a small practice checks whether payers paid the right amount
Most practices watch their denials closely, and they should. But a denial at least announces itself. An underpayment does not. The claim shows as paid, the balance moves to the patient or gets adjusted off, and nobody notices that the payer sent less than the contract says it should have. Over a year, those quiet shortfalls can add up to real money that the practice earned and never collected.
I have been around medical billing since 1991, when I started MedNet of Michigan in the early days of electronic claims. One habit that separated the practices that stayed healthy from the ones that struggled was simple: somebody actually checked what came in against what was expected. Here is a practical way for a small practice in Las Vegas or anywhere in Nevada to do that.
What counts as an underpayment
An underpayment is any time the allowed amount on the remittance is lower than the amount your contract or the payer’s published fee schedule says it should be for that service. Common causes include:
- The payer loaded the wrong fee schedule or an outdated one for your practice
- A modifier or multiple-procedure rule was applied in a way that does not match the contract
- The claim processed under the wrong provider, location or network status
- Bundling edits reduced or removed a line that should have paid
- Patient responsibility was calculated from the wrong plan or benefit
None of these are rare, and none of them show up as a denial. They only show up if you compare.
Step one: know what you should be paid
You cannot spot an underpayment without an expected amount. Gather your current contracts and fee schedules for your main payers and put the rates for your most common codes in one place. For most small practices, a short list of codes makes up the bulk of the volume, so start there rather than trying to load every code on day one.
If you cannot find a contract or a fee schedule, that is your first task. Ask the payer’s provider relations team for a copy. Many practices discover they have been operating for years without knowing their actual rates.
Step two: compare at posting time
The best moment to catch an underpayment is when the ERA or 835 is posted. If you post payments by hand or review auto-posted batches, add one check: does the allowed amount match the expected amount for that code and payer? Many practice management systems can store expected rates and flag variances automatically. If yours can, turn it on. If it cannot, a simple spreadsheet review of your top codes each week still catches most problems.
I wrote more about clean posting habits in how to post ERA and 835 payments in a small practice. Underpayment review fits right into that same routine.
Step three: look for patterns, not just single claims
One short payment might be a one-off. The same short payment on the same code from the same payer every week is a loading error, and it will keep happening until someone reports it. When you find a variance, check whether it repeats. A pattern is worth a phone call or a written inquiry to the payer, and it is often fixed for future claims once the payer corrects its setup.
Step four: ask for reprocessing
When you find an underpayment, the path is usually a reconsideration or reprocessing request rather than a full appeal, though every payer has its own process. Keep the request short and clear:
- The claim number, date of service, code and provider
- The amount paid and the amount expected
- The contract section or fee schedule that supports the expected amount
- A request to reprocess and, if it is a pattern, to correct the fee schedule going forward
If the payer says no and you still believe the contract supports you, move to a formal appeal. Our guide on writing a claim appeal letter a payer will read walks through that step. Watch the payer’s deadlines; underpayment disputes have time limits just like denials.
Step five: track it until it closes
Keep a simple log of every underpayment you dispute: date found, payer, amount, date requested and outcome. Review it monthly. That log tells you which payers need attention and gives you a record if you ever need to raise the issue at contract renewal. It also belongs in the monthly billing report a practice owner should read.
Do not forget the patient side
When a payer underpays, the patient’s share can be wrong too. If the payer corrects the claim, make sure the patient balance is corrected before a statement goes out. Patients remember billing mistakes, and getting their balance right is part of treating them with respect.
Where helpers fit
Comparing expected and actual payments is repetitive work, which makes it a good fit for automation that flags variances for a person to review. Our sister team at RemitReady Agents builds those kinds of office helpers. The decision about what to dispute still belongs to someone who knows the contracts.
Not sure your payers are paying what they agreed to? Request a free billing review or call (702) 775-1163. You can also email support@remitready.us. We will look at how your payments are posted and checked, and give you practical next steps whether or not you hire us. Read more posts on the RemitReady blog.