Clean claims before they leave the office: a pre-submission checklist for small practices
The cheapest denial is the one that never happens. A claim that goes out right the first time gets paid faster and never needs a phone call, a correction or an appeal. A claim that goes out with a small mistake can bounce back from the clearinghouse, get rejected by the payer, or get denied weeks later, and each of those costs staff time that nobody budgeted for.
Back in 1991, when I started MedNet of Michigan, we were batching claims to clearinghouses in the very early days of electronic billing. The single biggest lesson from those years still holds: most problems are simple, and most of them can be caught before the claim is sent. Here is the checklist I would use in a small practice in Las Vegas or anywhere in Nevada.
Rejections and denials are not the same thing
It helps to know the difference. A rejection means the claim never got into the payer’s system, usually because of missing or invalid data caught by the clearinghouse or the payer’s front-end edits. A rejected claim has not been processed, so it needs to be fixed and sent again, and the clock on timely filing keeps running. A denial means the payer received and processed the claim and decided not to pay all or part of it.
Rejections should be worked every day, because they are usually fast to fix and easy to lose track of. I covered why the clock matters in timely filing limits: how a small practice keeps claims from aging out.
Patient and insurance information
- Patient name and date of birth exactly as they appear on the insurance card
- Correct member ID and group number, with no extra characters
- Subscriber information correct when the patient is a dependent
- The right payer selected, including the right plan or managed care organization
- Primary and secondary insurance in the right order
Most of these are settled at the front desk. A short eligibility check before the visit, described in insurance eligibility verification before the visit, prevents more rejections than anything done later.
Provider and practice information
- Rendering and billing provider NPIs correct and in the right fields
- Tax ID and service location matching what the payer has on file
- The provider credentialed and enrolled with that payer for that location
- Referring provider included where the payer requires one
Provider data problems are frustrating because they often hit every claim for a provider at once. If a new clinician joins the practice, confirm enrollment before billing under their name. My payer credentialing checklist walks through that.
Coding and charges
- Procedure codes that match what the documentation supports
- Diagnosis codes that support each service and are linked to the right lines
- Modifiers applied where needed, and only where needed
- Units that match the documented time or quantity
- Place of service code correct, including telehealth where it applies
- Dates of service correct and not in the future
Coding questions should go to someone who knows the payer’s rules for that specialty. Behavioral health, for example, has its own habits around time-based codes, which I wrote about in behavioral health billing in Nevada.
Authorizations and attachments
If the service required prior authorization, the authorization number should be on the claim, and the dates and units billed should fall inside what was approved. If the payer requires documentation with the claim, make sure it is attached or sent the way the payer asks. A claim for an authorized service can still be denied if the authorization is not tied to it correctly.
Use your clearinghouse edits, then read the reports
Most practice management systems and clearinghouses run edits that flag common errors before the claim is sent. Turn them on and pay attention to them. Then read the acknowledgment and rejection reports every day. A claim is not “submitted” just because it left your system; it is submitted when the payer has accepted it.
Learn from your own mistakes
Once a month, look at the rejections and front-end denials you received and group them by cause. You will usually find that a few causes account for most of the trouble. Fix those at the source with a front desk script, a template change or a short staff refresher, and the next month gets easier.
Some practices also use automated assistants to handle the routine reminders, such as flagging an expiring authorization or a claim with no payer acknowledgment, while staff still make every decision. Our sister team at RemitReady Agents builds that kind of helper for offices.
Seeing the same rejections over and over? Request a free billing review or call (702) 775-1163. You can also email support@remitready.us. We will look at where your claims are getting stuck and give you practical fixes, whether or not you hire us. Read more posts on the RemitReady blog.